desserts, jeni's spinalong

Jeni’s Spinalong: PB+J Sandwich with Milk Ice Cream Terrine

the new "ice cream sandwich."

the new “ice cream sandwich.”

Because I’ve been known to make questionable (but exhilarating!) life decisions when I get stressed. Like, for example, turning to childhood foods for sustenance, then taking those foods and turning them into ice cream desserts.

Because life.

So this happened. If I think about it, it’s probably a combination of not having time to sit down during lunchtimes recently, and also packing lunch in a carousel horse-themed lunchbox for my child everyday. Whatever it is, it’s made my own childhood lunches come to mind, including my favorite sandwich, the Peanut Butter + Jelly.

PB+J with Milk Ice Cream Terrine

I don’t know what you grew up with, but this is how we made lunch back in the day. I still maintain a particular peanut-butter-to-jelly to bread ratio vastly different to Mr. Table’s ratios – he uses far too much peanut butter, and both his ingredients overtake the bread like a fast-motion lethal virus attacking a host) and the Wee’s – she’s Team Peanut Butter, solo.

I enjoy a modest spread of both: peanut butter barely coating bread in a thin layer, enough jelly to really taste it, but stopping short of messy. Bread can be classic white or wheat, but my favorite is a rye or pumpernickel – in life, really, but also with sandwiches.

PB+J with Milk Ice Cream Terrine

So it’s October, and I’m taking a breath between feature work. Doing the Spinalong with Natalie is palate-cleansing, for me: a way to think about food totally on my own, with her, but without restriction, and using someone else’s recipes versus having to create my own. You’d think all the recipe development and execution would make me weary of the kitchen, but it doesn’t: rather, I crave making other people’s recipes, because no thinking required.

Thanks to Jeni’s two cookbooks, I can give you this terrine: my take on what October feels like to me. It’s not quite cold yet everywhere; even here it waffles (mmm, waffles!) between near 90-degree temps and the rather chilly 40 degrees I woke up to this morning, which means it’s transitional weather perfect for PB + J’s.

PB+J with Milk Ice Cream Terrine

What’s going on here? Okay: so first you have a creamy peanut butter ice cream, made with a decidedly childlike peanut butter – Skippy Natural – which comes out tasting like every soft peanut butter candy you can think of. An unexpected outcome, to be sure, but a welcome one: the flavor closely resembles what you would taste if you ate 6 to 7 Reese’s Pieces and then did a shot of 2% milk to wash them down. The second thing happening is a sweet cream layer – not vanilla, just milky and soft, swirled with grape jelly and freckled with toast crumbs. As in, toast some of your favorite bread until it’s deeply toasty and then scrape it off into a bowl with a butter knife, then swirl that toasty flavor into your ice cream. Because toast.

I layered the whole dang thing into loaf pans this time, because we are talking about a sandwich after all, which would mean a “loaf” of some sort should be involved. So there you have it: a “loaf” of peanut butter and jelly ice cream with toast crumbs aka my October ice cream feels.

PB+J with Milk Ice Cream Terrine

Natalie did something equally entertaining, I think, and if you want to get technical, more suited to October than my own offering. She made Jeni’s Salty Vanilla Frozen Custard base and paired it with a perennial October favorite: Halloween candy. Her choice is classic Natalie: I feel as though I can say that with confidence. Have you noticed how incredibly “midwestern childhood” we get when fall hits? We do this every year, and it makes me happy in my heart. I’ll let her tell you about it over here.

Consider yourself October’d: I have a catch-up post waiting in the wings to publish after this, and I’m hoping the mass hysteria of a whole two posts in one month kickstarts some action over here. Until then, make yourself some PB+J terrines, and some Salty Vanilla Custard with Halloween Candy, kick back, and let the October wash over you.

Peanut Butter Ice Cream base just barely adapted from the recipe for Buckeye State Ice Cream from Jeni’s Splendid Ice Creams at Home, and “Milk” Ice cream a pretty straightforward copy of the Sweet Cream Ice Cream found in Jeni’s Splendid Ice Cream Desserts, both by the lovely and talented Jeni Britton Bauer.

PB+J Sandwich with Milk Ice Cream Terrines

for the peanut butter ice cream base:

  • 2 cups whole milk
  • 1 Tbsp + 1 tsp corn starch
  • 2 oz Philadelphia cream cheese
  • 1/2 cup creamy peanut butter – I used Skippy Natural for the most childhood-y flavor
  • 1/2 tsp kosher salt
  • 1 1/4 cups heavy cream
  • 2/3 cup sugar
  • 2 Tbsp light corn syrup
  • 2 Tbsp honey

for the sweet cream “milk” ice cream base: 

  • 2  2/3 cups whole milk
  • 1 Tbsp plus 2 teaspoons cornstarch
  • 2 oz cream cheese, at room temperature
  • 1/4 tsp kosher salt
  • 1 1/2 cups heavy cream
  • 3/4 cup granulated sugar
  • 1/4 cup light corn syrup (I use Karo)

for assembling the terrines / mix-ins:

  • 3 smallish loaf pans (the weirdos I use are 8 x 3 x 2 inches, but you can use two larger ones, if that’s what you have)
  • 2 Tbsp toast crumbs (made by toasting white bread and scraping the toasted surfaces with a butter knife into a small dish thankyouverymuch)
  • 1/2 cup Bonne Maman Muscat Grape Jelly or Strawberry Preserves (if you feel fancier than grape)

Make the Peanut Butter Ice Cream Base / 1st layer of terrines:

Fill a large bowl with ice water, set aside. Mix 2 tablespoons of the milk with the cornstarch in a small bowl and set aside. Add the cream cheese, peanut butter, and salt to a medium bowl; set aside.

Combine remaining milk, cream, sugar, corn syrup, and honey in a large sauce pan and bring to a rolling boil of medium-high heat; stir occasionally (which may be a tic of mine, but I just never want anything to burn.) Boil for 4 minutes, stirring frequently. Remove from heat, re-whisk your cornstarch slurry (it settles when it sits) and stream into the hot milk mixture, whisking constantly as you do.  Place pan back on burner and bring the mixture back to a boil and cook, stirring with a spatula until slightly thickened – 1 to 2 minutes.

Remove pan from heat and pour about a 1/2 cup into the cream cheese-peanut butter mixture; whisk until smooth and no cream cheese lumps remain, adding a little more of the hot milk mixture as needed. Pour the remaining hot milk mixture into the peanut butter-cream cheese mixture and whisk until smooth and homogenous. Set the bowl inside the larger water bath  bowl and whisk every so often to allow mixture to cool, about 45 minutes. Place in refrigerator to completely chill, at least 4 hours or overnight, which is how I typically roll with ice cream bases.

Pour ice cream base into the frozen canister of your ice cream maker and spin according to manufacturer’s instructions.

Line loaf pans with parchment paper, overhanging the long sides only (which means, obviously, that the short sides will be bare). When ice cream is ready, divide ice cream carefully into pans, aiming towards the center and then spreading out to the edges with a spoon. Once everything is even and smoothed, transfer to freezer and cover to freeze.

Make the Sweet Cream (“Glass of Milk”) Ice Cream Base / 2nd layer of terrines: 

Same as above, basically: in a large bowl (remember, this is the bowl your entire mixture will ultimately end up in), whisk together the cream cheese and salt.

In a small bowl, whisk together 2 tablespoons of the milk with the cornstarch until smooth. In a large, heavy-bottomed saucepan, whisk together the milk, cream, sugar and corn syrup. Bring to a boil over medium-high heat and continue to boil for 4 minutes. During the boil, re-whisk together the cornstarch mixture (it tends to settle to the bottom after a few minutes). Remove the milk mixture from heat, add the cornstarch slurry, and place back over heat to bring to a boil, stirring constantly. Allow to boil until thickened, 1 to 2 minutes. Remove from heat.

Pour a small amount of the hot milk mixture into the cream cheese mixture; whisk to combine until mixture is smooth and homogenous. Add remaining milk mixture and continue to whisk until everything is homogenous. Set the bowl inside the larger water bath  bowl and whisk every so often to allow mixture to cool, about 45 minutes. Place in refrigerator to completely chill, at least 4 hours or overnight.

Pour ice cream base into the frozen canister of your ice cream maker and spin according to manufacturer’s instructions. Meanwhile, pour grape or strawberry jam into a small microwave-safe bowl and heat for a few seconds at a time on high, until just beginning to melt. whisk to break up until jam is as smooth as it can be, but not hot (because it’s going into ice cream, silly.)

Once ice cream is ready, remove canister from the ice cream maker and stir in toast crumbs using a spatula until evenly distributed. Remove the loaf pans from the freezer and add a few small spoonfuls of jam to the frozen peanut butter ice cream. Add a few big spoonfuls of the “milk” ice cream over top, spread a little with the back of a spoon, then add more small spoonfuls of jam; you’re going for a swirl, so spoon jam accordingly, ending with a few drops of jam at the end. Use a butter knife to swirl the mixture ever so slightly, then cover and place back into the freezer to set up, at least 4 hours or, as usual, overnight.

And now, you slice and eat. Use a thin knife to loosen up the naked short sides, then lift the ice cream loaves out using the parchment handles. Set on your work surface, slice up, and serve.

You Might Also Like


  • Reply Faygie October 1, 2015 at 8:10 pm

    This looks INCREDIBLE!! I’m a big fan of PB&J sandwiches, although unlike you I like them with lots of PB&J 🙂

  • Reply Brianne October 2, 2015 at 7:50 am

    I dig this! Innovative and clever. If this is palate-cleansing for you, your feature work must be bomb. I had a mad affair with PB&J–every day, two pieces of whole grain bread slathered with loads of both PB and J–until about a year ago. These days they don’t do it for me, but I can definitely get down with a loaf of PB&J ice cream!!

  • Reply natalie @ wee eats October 2, 2015 at 9:14 am

    I seriously DIE over this ice cream, and I’m glad one of us got to make our childhood ice cream dreams come true! This is one I’M DEFINITELY making. Maybe it will be my ‘birthday cake’ (terrine) next year. Yes, I think that would be just lovely.

  • Reply Willow | Will Cook For Friends October 3, 2015 at 2:20 pm

    I’m with you on the PB&J sandwich ratios — I’m very particular about the amount of filling-to-bread. Too much and the whole sandwich is ruined! I’ve never tried using rye or pumpernickel for PB&J’s, though, so now that’s going straight on my to-try list… right along with this ice cream. No joke, I’ve been swirling peanut butter into plain vanilla ice cream every night for the past couple of weeks to satisfy my own fall childhood cravings, so I feel like we’re riding the same wave here. 🙂

  • Reply movita beaucoup October 11, 2015 at 7:31 am

    I’m going to need to see that carousel horse-themed lunchbox.

    • Reply shannon November 11, 2015 at 12:34 pm

      oh i will TOTALLY send you a photo. i also purchased the matching backpack…as one does when they find something printed with carousel horses, you know.

  • Reply Amy @ Elephant Eats October 12, 2015 at 10:11 am

    Love this dessert, Shannon! It’s so pretty…and very creative 🙂 I’m pretty sure I’d love it. I think my ideal pb:j ratio sounds more similar to Mr. Table’s. For some reason I think of childhood pb&j as soft white bread with a thick layer of pb and so much grape jelly that it oozes out the sides. Any other kind may be delicious, but does NOT remind me of childhood. I could go for one right about now, in fact…

    • Reply shannon November 11, 2015 at 12:33 pm

      That’s a really accurate description of most people’s childhood PBJ’s, for sure: you gotta cram as much in there as possible if your mom is only going to let you have one sandwich, right? 🙂 it really is the quintessential sandwich of youth: i know i ate other sandwiches – plenty – but none really transports me back to when i was 7 than this one. I still eat them sometimes when i’m thinking about them.

  • Reply salted peanut butter + jelly blondies. – A Periodic Table January 21, 2016 at 2:44 pm

    […] I think by now you know that I love peanut butter in jelly, always, in all ways. […]

  • Leave a Reply